Is the Stock AMD Cooler Enough for Ryzen 5900X? Find Out!

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. testing the Stock AMD Cooler
3. Comparing the Stock Cooler with the Dark Rock Slim
4. The Performance Results
5. Factors to Consider When Choosing a CPU Cooler
6. Pros and Cons of Using the Stock AMD Cooler
7. Pros and Cons of Using the Dark Rock Slim
8. Conclusion
9. FAQs
10. Resources

Introduction

In this article, we will be discussing the performance of the stock AMD cooler that comes with the Ryzen 9 5000 series CPUs. We will compare it to the Dark Rock Slim cooler and determine if it is a good idea to use the stock cooler for this high-performance CPU. We will conduct CPU stress tests and analyze the temperature results to understand the limitations of the stock cooler. Additionally, we will explore the reasons why AMD does not provide this cooler when you purchase their 5000 series CPUs.

Testing the Stock AMD Cooler

The stock AMD Ryzen CPU coolers are typically rated for 65 watts or slightly higher. However, the Ryzen 9 5000 CPUs are rated for 105 watts, which exceeds the capabilities of the stock cooler. While the stock cooler is adequate for lower-end CPUs and non-overclocking situations, using it for a high-performance CPU like the Ryzen 9 5900X can result in thermal throttling and even CPU shutdown.

To determine the performance of the stock cooler, we conducted a CPU stress test on the Ryzen 9 5900X using the stock AMD cooler. The results showed that the CPU temperature reached 90 degrees Celsius within minutes, with occasional spikes up to 91 degrees Celsius. These temperatures are quite high for a CPU, especially considering that the test was conducted on an open bench in a cooler environment.

Comparing the Stock Cooler with the Dark Rock Slim

To improve the cooling performance, we decided to compare the stock cooler with a higher-performance aftermarket cooler, the Dark Rock Slim. The Dark Rock Slim is a beefier cooler with a 180-watt TDP rating, featuring four heat pipes and a 120mm fan.

During the comparison, we observed a significant difference in idle temperatures. With the stock cooler, the Ryzen 9 5900X idled at around 39-40 degrees Celsius, while the Dark Rock Slim reduced the idle temperature to 30 degrees Celsius. This indicates that the Dark Rock Slim is more efficient at dissipating heat even during low CPU usage.

The Performance Results

After installing the Dark Rock Slim and conducting another CPU stress test, we noticed a considerable improvement in temperature management. With the Dark Rock Slim, the CPU temperatures reached a peak of 68 degrees Celsius, and after five minutes of stress testing, settled at around 78 degrees Celsius. This represented a 13-degree difference compared to the stock cooler, highlighting the effectiveness of the aftermarket cooler in keeping the CPU temperature under control.

It is important to note that these results were obtained in an open test bench environment. In real-world scenarios, temperatures may vary depending on factors such as case airflow and overall system cooling. However, the Dark Rock Slim proved to be a suitable option for the Ryzen 9 5900X, offering efficient cooling performance at an affordable price point of around $60.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a CPU Cooler

When selecting a CPU cooler, there are several factors to consider:

1. TDP Rating: Make sure the cooler's TDP rating is sufficient to handle the heat produced by your CPU.
2. Airflow and Fan Size: Consider the design of the cooler and ensure that it fits within your PC case while providing adequate airflow.
3. Noise Levels: Some coolers can be noisier than others, so choose one that meets your preferences for noise levels.
4. Overclocking Capability: If you plan to overclock your CPU, consider investing in a more robust cooler to handle the increased heat generated.

Pros and Cons of Using the Stock AMD Cooler

Pros:

• Free: The stock cooler comes included with the CPU, saving you the cost of purchasing an aftermarket cooler.
• Sufficient for Lower-End CPUs: The stock cooler is suitable for non-overclocking and lower-power CPUs.

Cons:

• Limited Cooling Performance: The stock cooler is not designed to handle the high heat output of high-performance CPUs.
• Noisy: Under heavy loads, the stock cooler can become noisy due to its smaller fan size and less efficient cooling design.

Pros and Cons of Using the Dark Rock Slim

Pros:

• Improved Cooling Performance: The Dark Rock Slim significantly reduces CPU temperatures compared to the stock cooler, allowing for more stable performance.
• Affordable: The Dark Rock Slim offers a cost-effective solution for users seeking better CPU cooling performance without breaking the bank.
• Compatibility: The compact design of the Dark Rock Slim ensures compatibility with most PC cases.

Cons:

• Size and Installation: The beefier size of the Dark Rock Slim may cause installation challenges in small cases with limited space.
• No RGB Lighting: If you are looking for RGB lighting aesthetics, the Dark Rock Slim may not fulfill that requirement.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the stock AMD cooler may be sufficient for lower-end CPUs and non-overclocking scenarios, it is not recommended for high-performance CPUs like the Ryzen 9 5000 series. The Dark Rock Slim, on the other HAND, provides efficient cooling performance at an affordable price point, making it a suitable option for users seeking improved temperature management for their high-performance CPUs. Consider your specific requirements and budget when selecting a CPU cooler, and choose one that can handle the heat output of your CPU while ensuring no thermal throttling or performance degradation.

FAQs

Q: Why doesn't AMD provide the Dark Rock Slim cooler with their 5000 series CPUs? A: AMD does not provide aftermarket coolers like the Dark Rock Slim with their CPUs as they aim to deliver a balance between price and performance for their customers. The stock cooler is sufficient for most users, and those seeking better cooling performance can opt for aftermarket coolers based on their individual needs.

Q: Can I use the stock AMD cooler for gaming on a high-performance CPU? A: While the stock cooler may manage temperatures adequately for gaming on non-overclocked high-performance CPUs, it is advisable to upgrade to a more powerful cooler to ensure optimal temperature management. Higher CPU usage in gaming scenarios may lead to increased temperatures, and using an aftermarket cooler like the Dark Rock Slim can provide more efficient cooling.

Q: Is it necessary to use an aftermarket cooler for non-overclocked lower-end CPUs? A: No, it is not necessary to use an aftermarket cooler for non-overclocked lower-end CPUs. The stock cooler included with these CPUs is designed to handle the heat output within their TDP rating. However, if you notice higher temperatures or prefer quieter operation, upgrading to an aftermarket cooler may still be beneficial.

Resources

• AMD: https://www.amd.com
• be quiet!: https://www.bequiet.com
• Dark Rock Slim Cooler: https://www.bequiet.com/en/cpucooler/1998